About
Archives
|
Cornell Faculty Affirm: A Cornell Degree Must Be Earned
The issue of whether or not Weill Cornell would be able to award honorary degrees was brought to the Faculty Senate for a vote yesterday. The Cornell Alumni Magazine broke the decision with their exclusive story today: In a memo, Hajjar and two colleagues wrote: “Such a honoris causa ad gradum would enable us to recognize outstanding intellectual achievements, creative accomplishments, and leadership in education, public service, medical ethics, or other appropriate sectors of society, both nationally and internationally. We view this goal as consonant with the fundamental mission of the University.” But many Ithaca faculty disagreed, arguing that the criteria for selection were too broad and the process potentially open to abuse; they also noted that Cornell’s refusal to grant honorary degrees is a longstanding tradition beloved by some alumni. In the past, some faculty have expressed suspicion that the driving force behind the change is the desire for a fundraising tool. Says neurobiology and behavior professor Howard Howland: “The tradition of not awarding honorary degrees is an old and venerable one, but as useful as ever in insuring that honorary degrees should not devalue the University’s earned degrees.” A full copy of Hajjar's letter may be found here. The most interesting sentence asserts that, "The University should be careful that the awarding of a degree not be political motivated or appear to be so." So one would hope that Weill Cornell never intended to honor wealthy benefactors with such a degree... even if they are the Emir of Qatar or the the former Chairman of Citigroup. But we have our suspicions. This may not be the last time we hear about this issue. Matthew Nagowski | May 15, 2008 (#) More 2008 Waitlist News So as our nice follow-up to the story that Cornell does not look to be taking many students off the waitlist... yet, the Undergraduate Admissions Office sent out the following email to all waitlisted students yesterday: Thank you for your continued interest in Cornell University. Since you have elected to remain on our waiting list, I am writing to provide you with an update. As of today, we have made a limited number of offers of admission from the waiting list for our School of Hotel Administration. Although there is still a possibility that we may extend offers of admission for Cornell's other colleges and schools, we are not prepared to do so at this time. We should have another update for you during the week of May 26, or you may hear from us sooner if we are able to extend an offer of admission to you. With best regards, Jason C. Locke So, as we suspected, it's really going to hinge on how many currently enrolled students at Cornell get off the waitlist from other schools and decide to attend those schools instead. If this doesn't happen, it would be the first year in three years that Cornell hasn't had to aggressively use the waitlist. Matthew Nagowski | May 15, 2008 (#) Putting The Odds on a Chancellorship So the Wisconsin press is just full of gushing articles about Biddy Martin, and her consideration for the UW-Madison chancellorship. And Biddy is just gushing in return: We have to assume that if Biddy is given the opportunity, she will take it. So what's the possibility that she is selected? There are three other candidates, so one might think that the probability might be one in four. But we're going to go out on a limb and put the odds that Biddy leaves Cornell for Wisconsin at closer to 70 to 80 percent. Simply put, Biddy is the most qualified for the job. None of the other three candidates have managed the day to day operations of a large research university for the last eight years. But Biddy has, and she has done a pretty admirable job during her tenure at Cornell. Either way, we'll know by early June. So let's assume that Biddy gets the job. How does that affect Cornell? The capital campaign? And Biddy's various initiatives? For the time being, we think David Harris will be named interim provost. After all, he's been the deputy provost for close to a year now. But then it will be interesting to see who the next provost will be. If the last two provosts of Cornell have gone on to the top spots at the University of Chicago and the University of Wisconsin, there's no denying the fact that the provost position at Cornell is highly coveted within the ivy-coated walls of academia. Matthew Nagowski | May 14, 2008 (#) Waitlist Woes The whispers we have been hearing out of the Cornell admissions offices is that the various colleges mostly met their yield targets, and that only certain schools -- like the Hotel School -- are turning to the waitlist. Last year, Cornell accepted nearly 10 percent of its entering class out of the waitlist. But we're not holding our breadth: "This year has been less predictable than any recent year," said Eric J. Kaplan, interim dean of admissions at Penn, adding that when one college in the top tier goes deep into its wait list, others are affected. "We all need to fill our classes and replace students who have been taken off wait lists at other institutions. The wait-list activity could extend for a significant time." Although colleges turn to wait lists to fill out their classes, it is unusual for the most selective to go so deep, college officials say. The implications are clear: Even if Cornell has met its enrollment targets for the time being, the aggressive use of waitlists at certain institutions known for winning the common-admit battle with Cornell (e.g. Harvard, Princeton), may mean that Cornell may see the number of committed students dropping, possibly forcing Cornell itself to turn to the waitlist. It's similar to trickle down effect on the economy popularized by Republican Presidential candidates, except, you know, in this setting it actually has an effect. Of course, financial considerations aside, why somebody wouldn't want to spend four years in Ithaca, NY is beyond me. The can live in cities like Boston for the rest of their life. Matthew Nagowski | May 13, 2008 (#) Coming Soon: A Free Cornell Magazine? No, the University hasn't suddenly given the Cornell Alumni Federation and the Cornell Alumni Magazine the money that is needed to circulate their magazine free to all Cornell alumni. But it may be the next best thin, as the gray lady reports: Mr. Kim will stay as publisher. Tom Allon, president and chief executive of Manhattan Media, said he hoped the executive editor, Richard Bradley, would also stay. The magazine will go from four issues a year to six, he said. “We plan to launch a companion Web site that’s a social networking Web site for Harvard alumni, and sponsor a series of events, alumni events, around the 02138 brand,” he said. “We think this is a sort of new paradigm in publishing. I think people do share common interests when they’re alumni of a university.” Over the next few years, Mr. Allon said, “Our plan is that this is the first of what will become eight Ivy League magazines, sites and events companies,” one each for Brown, Columbia, Cornell, Dartmouth, Penn, Princeton and Yale. Though he is an alumnus of Cornell and Columbia, Mr. Allon said the next project would probably be Yale or Princeton. The magazine, mailed free to about 100,000 Harvard alumni, is supported by ads, and the other magazines would follow that lead. “Paid circulation, I think, is a dying model,” [Allon] said. Tom Allon received his A.B. from Cornell in 1984. It will be interesting to see how this all plays out. First, I don't think Cornell alums navel gaze nearly as much as some of their Ivy peers. Let's face it: a plant botanist or materials science engineer probably won't be very interested in how alums are dressed in California. Secondly, it will create some competition for the present Alumni Magazine, as well as for the Daily Sun, and blogs like this one. But if you ask us, competition is always a good thing. So is more people writing about Cornell. And the fact that it will be free and distributed to all alums is just icing on the cake. Also, any guesses on what they will name the Cornell-centric magazine? I hope they don't go with 14853. After all, there already is a magazine called 14850. Let's hope they go for something with a nice Cornelliana ring to it. But remember, "Far Beyond Cayuga's Waters" is already taken. Matthew Nagowski | May 12, 2008 (#) The View From The Crescent MetaEzra made a pilgrimage to Ithaca -- our darling Ithaca -- yesterday. Over the course of the day we connected with old friends and new, soaked in some facetime at CTB, dined on The Commons, indulged ourselves at the Cayuga Lake Creamery, and enjoyed the first round of the NCAA lacrosse tournament with a game between Cornell and The Ohio State University. Loyal readers, no doubt, will recall that last year MetaEzra followed the lacrosse team in carnelian and white all the way to Baltimore. That said, we would rather not talk about yesterday's lacrosse game. Suffice to say that we think Duke will have its hands full against the Buckeyes next week. We're also hoping that Cornell senior and lacrosse player Danny Nathan, who has been blogging for the NYTimes this week, will be able to fill us in on exactly what happened out on the field. But this was the first time that we ever took in a game at Schoellkopf amidst such bona fide weather. The view from the Crescent to the rolling countryside in the west is unbelievable, especially in the face of a setting sun, and a glaring silhouette of McGraw Tower. Upon consideration, it might be one of the most striking views available at any sports stadium in the country. ![]() Complete with tailgating on Kite Hill before the event, we began to get the feeling of what Stanford would be like. Matthew Nagowski | May 11, 2008 (#) Fictionalized Cornell In last week's CSI episode on CBS, a chess tournament between the Cornell University Chess Club and the Las Vegas Detention Center was featured prominently, with over a minute of air time dedicated to a Cornell student check-mating an inmate. The relevant scene can be found at 9:13 of this clip. Here's a screen shot: ![]() Why in the world would Cornell students be playing chess in Nevada? Well, some alums might have something to do with it. At least the Cornell Image Committee should be happy, as "cool hoodies" were featured prominently. This clip ties in nicely with a recent article in the Alumni Magazine about fictionalized Cornell and Cornellians. The article showcased a lot of fictional Cornellians in a positive light, but also explored the phenomena of negative Cornell images in the media: But Cornell-educated protagonists seem to be matched in nearly equal numbers by less desirable characters. For every Gabrielle Ashe (a U.S. Senator's aide who courageously ends her corrupt boss's career in Dan Brown's thriller Deception Point), there is a Bobby Earl (a rapist and murderer played by Blair Under-wood in the movie Just Cause). For every Eric Erickson, a Swedish industrialist who masquerades as a Nazi sympathizer to spy on the Germans during World War II in Alexander Klein's 1958 novel The Counterfeit Traitor (William Holden played him in the movie), there is a Taro Seki, a Japanese engineering grad who grew to love America while in Ithaca but changes his tune upon joining the Japanese army during that same war (in the propaganda film Behind the Rising Sun)... Personally, I always have suspected that characters like Andy Bernard or Sideshow Mel are just pranks being played on Cornell by screenwriters who happen to have graduated from other Ivy League schools... namely Harvard. After all, Harvard has a reputation for producing a lot of Hollywood screenwriters for shows like The Office or The Simpsons. But it is nice to know that Cornell screenwriters are looking out for their alma mater too... by having the chess club beat a bunch of Las Vegas prisoners. Now they just need to start taking pot shots at Harvard. Matthew Nagowski | May 08, 2008 (#) Goodbye Biddy? It's of course too early to say our goodbyes just yet, as Biddy is just a finalist, and has not yet actually been chosen as the Chancellor for UW-Madison, but I have to imagine she may be considered the leading contender for the position in many circles. After all, she is widely respected in academia, credited for wrestling Cornell's suffering bureaucracy to the ground and implementing a lot cross-disciplinary initiatives, and was The breaking news out of the Badger State today: The candidates are: Gary Sandefur, dean of UW-Madison's College of Letters and Sciences; Biddy (Carolyn) Martin, Provost of Cornell University in New York; R. Timothy Mulcahy, vice president for research at the University of Minnesota; and Rebecca Blank, former dean of the Gerald R. Ford School of Public Policy at the University of Michigan. Of course, Biddy completed her PhD in German literature in 1985 from the University of Wisconsin–Madison, so this would be a homecoming for her. Late Thought: Did Biddy actually see this coming by naming a Deputy Provost last year? Probably not, but it would help to ease the transition. Matthew Nagowski | May 07, 2008 (#) The Enduring Value of a Cornell Degree Forget about all of the Cornell Career Services propaganda, you don't have to look any further than this very website to see how far a degree from Cornell University can take you. You see, now three years out from earning our degrees (and only two years away from our first reunion!), Andy and myself have reached the pinnacle of professional and personal success: But I suppose it could be worse. After all, we could be Kevin Vanginderen ’83 who is inexplicably and frivolously suing the University for something as innocuous as offering digital archives of the Cornell Chronicle. (Here's a hint, Kevin, if you are trying to protect your past, don't commit actions that are going to make you even more Googleable.) Or, we could always be Ann "poll tax" Coulter '84. *I'll concede that we are at least still gainfully employed and both have rather legitimate reasons to be living with our parents. Matthew Nagowski | May 05, 2008 (#) Faithful No More? Mitchell Alva and Elie Blimes penned a much needed op-ed in today's Sun regarding the University's treatment of the Lynah Faithful in recent years: As Cornell has missed the NCAA tournament each of the last two years, a supportive, vocal fan base is more valuable than ever — we suggest several policy changes for the upcoming season to revive that fan base. First, we need to improve the ticket lottery system. As it stands, there is no mechanism to ensure that the most dedicated fans have an opportunity to receive tickets. A return to general admission seating would improve the Lynah atmosphere, as the most dedicated fans who arrive earliest could sit wherever they please amongst student seats. We would also love to see Athletics organize bus trips. These exciting journeys would provide an easy opportunity for students without cars to see the team on the road and would cultivate a new generation of devoted Lynah Faithful.... As dedicated fans, we have spent considerable time, money and effort following Cornell hockey, and it isn’t too much to ask that our efforts be appreciated... For many of us, hockey is a highlight of our Cornell experience. Please don’t ruin it. I suspect that one of the reasons for the high price of hockey tickets was the 2005 renovation of Lynah Rink, in order to make the Cornell facilities more attractive to Schaefer's recruits. But even so, I don't think a college hockey game should cost more than a movie at the local cinemas. But more generally, the University should be doing everything in its power to make the student athletics experience positive, not negative. The current hockey ticket lottery is ridiculous in this regard, as it does nothing to reward those who really make Cornell hockey what it is -- the Lynah Faithful. Is the University really too scared to simply say: "Tickets go on sale at 6PM on Sunday. Please get in line when you wish?" Start to assign line numbers at 6PM the day before, and have random number checks throughout the 24 hour period. Any line issues before that time should be student regulated -- perhaps by the Pep Band? I doubt anybody would show up before Friday night, and that would certainly be the most equitable, safe, and exciting way to dole out tickets, especially considering they are already making the students sleep overnight in Bartels. Might as well make it worth something. I'm more torn about the busing. Ideally, Athletics doesn't really need to be involved. I'm certain some intrepid student group or fraternity could do the leg work to organize bus trips to the Harvard or Princeton games. And I bet they could even get funding from it at the SAFC. Matthew Nagowski | May 01, 2008 (#) |
-- No it's not the groundbreaking of Milstein Hall... but its close to it -- Lake Source Cooling effects to be reevaluated -- President Emeritus Rawlings: Visiting professor, and now commencement speaker, at U.Va. -- Biddy Martin: "I am positioned well to be at Wisconsin" -- One profile of a student who turned down Cornell... for Harvard -- Cornell secures 6th and 7th Ivy titles of the year, with a sweep at heps -- Ball dropped on Collegetown Creeper -- New Blog: The Essentials -- Cornell to start lowering tuition... for graduate students -- Binghamton Student dies in alcohol related crash... student was in Ithaca for Slope Day festivities -- Rain on Slope Day... live view -- We don't need no stinkin' journalism major! -- A math comic: ai + b -- Will the longest rivalry in lacrosse -- Cornell v. Hobart -- be no more? -- This makes the Milstein Hall fiasco tame by comparison ![]() -- The Swan Song of Rob Fishman (Nagowski) -- College Tuition and the Credit Crisis (Nagowski) -- Cornell's Financial Aid Woes (Nagowski) -- Weill Cornell: The Man Behind the School (Nagowski) -- Variations of Minesweeper at Cornell (Nagowski) -- Congratulations to Mike Walsh (Nagowski) -- How To Pick Your College (Nagowski) -- A Follow Up With Paau (Nagowski) -- More Info On Class of 2012 Admissions (Nagowski) -- Where's My Class Notes? (Nagowski) -- The Sun -- A Chat With Farhad Manjoo (AGuess) -- Cornell To Drop Out of Ivy League!!! (Nagowski) -- Cornell's New CyberLibrarian (AGuess) -- Uncle Ezra On Jepoardy! (Nagowski) -- Going Dancin': Ivy League History Made (Nagowski) -- Burn The Dragon! (Nagowski) -- Cornell's Newest Trustee? (Nagowski) -- Is Cornell The Most Generous Ivy? (Nagowski) -- Whither the Ivy League? (Nagowski) ![]() |